Controversial metal opinions[views:34239][posts:200]__________________________________________ [Mar 23,2008 8:37am - corpus_colostomy ""] atthehaunted said:Isn't this thread about Master of Puppets or Peace Sells? Damn u guys have ADD or some shit haha But I root for Master let the record show this is about controversial metal opinions...which, as you might glean, seem to be epitomized by the metallica vs megadeth argument. those who are digressing into other 'metal topics,' are well within the scope of this thread. we don't have ADD you just don't know how to read... |
| _____________________________________________ [Mar 23,2008 10:25am - aterribleguitarist ""] Controvertial metal opinion? Grand Declaration of War = Mayhem's best album Ordo Ad Chao = boring, unlistenable shit |
| ___________________________________________________ [Mar 23,2008 10:39am - now in kadoog-a-vision! ""] OlafFromRussia said: ...oh yeah. Controversial thoughts on metal. Most metal heads are close minded, pathetic, hypocritical pricks. They grow into this shit because they're sick of the establishment, denounce authoritarianism, and look at what they become. These people are just like Catholics. Act like us, dress like us, do what we do, or prepare for inquisition. And then you have the pricks who cry and complain about girls or just beat the shit out of them, and yet they wonder why good looking classy women want nothing to do with them... which just feeds the cycle. Or the 20 something yr olds who think they're brutal, but they live in the suburbs with their mom and stay clear from the same black neighborhoods as everyone else. What an amusing counter-culture. YES! Russian man for the win. |
| ________________________________________ [Mar 23,2008 4:15pm - DestroyYouAlot ""] OlafFromRussia said:Killing Is My Business = RtL > Kill'Em All MoP > Peace Sells > ...aJFA > So Far So Good... RIP > ...aJFA Youthinasia > CTE = S/T MATH, LOL |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 23,2008 7:43pm - dreadkill ""] KPANZER said:The Jon Corabi MOTLEY CRUE record is amazing.probably their best album |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 23,2008 7:49pm - dreadkill ""] menstrual_sweatpants_disco said:Fuck reading this whole thread. I'll just state my opinion and leave. 95% of death metal = boring. you are being generous. i say 99% of death metal is boring crap with appliance vocals and no memorable riffs. i like older death metal, but i could probably count on one hand the amount of good death metal records released in the last five years. good death metal worth listening to is a rarity these days. every other genre of metal > death metal. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 23,2008 7:50pm - dreadkill ""] yummy said: Beneath the Remains>Arise>Schizophrenia>Chaos AD(didn't care too much for it). switch the order of btr and arise and that's how my list goes too. |
| ____________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 8:21am - i_am_lazy ""] ZJD said:Gallows Gallery > Hail Horror Hail Whoa, I love Gallows Gallery, but I still think I prefer Hail Horror Hail. |
| ____________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 8:22am - i_am_lazy ""] alexc said:Testament deserves more fame and success than slayer and anthrax combine. Nah. Slayer and Anthrax can at least sound halfway decent live. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 9:39am - contagion ""] i like the new megadeth song sleepwalker |
| _______________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 12:24pm - Karma-Enema ""] dreadkill said: menstrual_sweatpants_disco said:Fuck reading this whole thread. I'll just state my opinion and leave. 95% of death metal = boring. you are being generous. i say 99% of death metal is boring crap with appliance vocals and no memorable riffs. i like older death metal, but i could probably count on one hand the amount of good death metal records released in the last five years. good death metal worth listening to is a rarity these days. every other genre of metal > death metal. this coming from someone praising motley crue doesnt have much weight. and how idiotic the rest of you are.....ohh this bands better than that band and this albums greater than that one... metallica vs megadeth ! slayer vs sepultura ! further proof of an intelligence lacking local scene :pukeface: |
| ______________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 12:32pm - ouchdrummer ""] I think puppets was better than peace sells, but i will admit i thought the solos on kill em all that mustane wrote were better than most hammet solos through his whole career. |
| __________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 12:33pm - Martins ""] dreadkill said: menstrual_sweatpants_disco said:Fuck reading this whole thread. I'll just state my opinion and leave. 95% of death metal = boring. you are being generous. i say 99% of death metal is boring crap with appliance vocals and no memorable riffs. i like older death metal, but i could probably count on one hand the amount of good death metal records released in the last five years. good death metal worth listening to is a rarity these days. every other genre of metal > death metal. The problem with death metal these days is a lack of focus on songwriting. A lot of bands just try to go for that whole wall of sound approach to sound brutal or be heavy. While sometimes that's awesome it absolutely sucks. If bands started actually concentrating on what they were playing then maybe death metal could turn around. This, of course, does not apply to all death metal bands because there are more than enough that know what they are doing out there. |
| ____________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 12:36pm - dreadkill ""] Karma-Enema said: dreadkill said: menstrual_sweatpants_disco said:Fuck reading this whole thread. I'll just state my opinion and leave. 95% of death metal = boring. you are being generous. i say 99% of death metal is boring crap with appliance vocals and no memorable riffs. i like older death metal, but i could probably count on one hand the amount of good death metal records released in the last five years. good death metal worth listening to is a rarity these days. every other genre of metal > death metal. this coming from someone praising motley crue doesnt have much weight. and how idiotic the rest of you are.....ohh this bands better than that band and this albums greater than that one... metallica vs megadeth ! slayer vs sepultura ! further proof of an intelligence lacking local scene :pukeface: i never praised motley crue, so that shows how unintelligent you are. i said the corabi album is probably the best motley crue album. i never said i was a fan of motley crue. a few songs here and there are ok, but overall, i think motley crue sucks. your anonymous opinion doesn't carry much weight. i don't understand how people mentioning which bands and albums they like better than others shows proof of a lack of intelligence. these people aren't misrepresenting factual information, they're simply expressing their opinions. |
| ____________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 12:37pm - dreadkill ""] Martins said: dreadkill said: menstrual_sweatpants_disco said:Fuck reading this whole thread. I'll just state my opinion and leave. 95% of death metal = boring. you are being generous. i say 99% of death metal is boring crap with appliance vocals and no memorable riffs. i like older death metal, but i could probably count on one hand the amount of good death metal records released in the last five years. good death metal worth listening to is a rarity these days. every other genre of metal > death metal. The problem with death metal these days is a lack of focus on songwriting. A lot of bands just try to go for that whole wall of sound approach to sound brutal or be heavy. While sometimes that's awesome it absolutely sucks. If bands started actually concentrating on what they were playing then maybe death metal could turn around. This, of course, does not apply to all death metal bands because there are more than enough that know what they are doing out there. i'm with you. the songwriting is horrendous these days in death metal. it's more of a pissing contest about who can be more brutal and whose vocalist can sound like the biggest kitchen appliance. |
| ____________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 12:58pm - contagion ""] dreadkill said: Martins said: dreadkill said: menstrual_sweatpants_disco said:Fuck reading this whole thread. I'll just state my opinion and leave. 95% of death metal = boring. you are being generous. i say 99% of death metal is boring crap with appliance vocals and no memorable riffs. i like older death metal, but i could probably count on one hand the amount of good death metal records released in the last five years. good death metal worth listening to is a rarity these days. every other genre of metal > death metal. The problem with death metal these days is a lack of focus on songwriting. A lot of bands just try to go for that whole wall of sound approach to sound brutal or be heavy. While sometimes that's awesome it absolutely sucks. If bands started actually concentrating on what they were playing then maybe death metal could turn around. This, of course, does not apply to all death metal bands because there are more than enough that know what they are doing out there. i'm with you. the songwriting is horrendous these days in death metal. it's more of a pissing contest about who can be more brutal and whose vocalist can sound like the biggest kitchen appliance. nothing more dissatisfying than getting pumped for a new CD only to have it be a piece of shit metal by numbers brutality contest. |
| _______________________________ [Mar 24,2008 1:03pm - aril ""] curious, but what would your opinions be on the .01% of good death metal bands today? i've been listening to ache er cock's Antichrist album a lot..I'd throw them in that .01% |
| ___________________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 1:07pm - FuckIsMySignature ""] i'd like to see Marilyn Manson's approach to a Black Metal project. |
| _________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 1:10pm - Martins ""] aril said:curious, but what would your opinions be on the .01% of good death metal bands today? i've been listening to ache er cock's Antichrist album a lot..I'd throw them in that .01% I'm the kind of guy who's willing to try any metal. That 0.01% of death metal is usually amazing. Akercocke's Antichrist isn't bad but there are parts when it gets really dull and deteriorates to sections of songs that have no impact. I don't know if they're amazing but I guess they're not bad. My #1 favorite band is Spawn of Possession. Whatever anyone says about it, no one can deny that Jonas Brysling knows what he's doing. His songwriting is amazing. Also, to add to the metal opinion controversy, Meshuggah is terrible. So bad. It's a bunch of pseudo-technical riffs thrown over nonsensical drums with a cymbal hit every quarter note. It's not brutal or mind-blowing. It's dumb. |
| ______________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 1:13pm - Karma-Enema ""] >> i never praised motley crue, so that shows how unintelligent you are. i said the corabi album is probably the best motley crue album. i never said i was a fan of motley crue. a few songs here and there are ok, but overall, i think motley crue sucks. your anonymous opinion doesn't carry much weight. i don't understand how people mentioning which bands and albums they like better than others shows proof of a lack of intelligence. these people aren't misrepresenting factual information, they're simply expressing their opinions.>> ok so i ASSumed you were a fan since you know their music and comment freely on it . so sorry . my opinion held enough weight for a response from you. but how can one compare one band to another ? does one compare beers to wine ? beers are better than wine but i would eat grapes before hops anyday . love french fries but i hate vodka |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 1:17pm - dreadkill ""] aril said:curious, but what would your opinions be on the .01% of good death metal bands today? i've been listening to ache er cock's Antichrist album a lot..I'd throw them in that .01% i like akercocke but i think they mix too many styles to be considered death metal. i just never really think of them as a death metal band. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 1:28pm - dreadkill ""] Karma-Enema said: i never praised motley crue, so that shows how unintelligent you are. i said the corabi album is probably the best motley crue album. i never said i was a fan of motley crue. a few songs here and there are ok, but overall, i think motley crue sucks. your anonymous opinion doesn't carry much weight. i don't understand how people mentioning which bands and albums they like better than others shows proof of a lack of intelligence. these people aren't misrepresenting factual information, they're simply expressing their opinions. ok so i ASSumed you were a fan since you know their music and comment freely on it . so sorry . my opinion held enough weight for a response from you. but how can one compare one band to another ? does one compare beers to wine ? beers are better than wine but i would eat grapes before hops anyday . love french fries but i hate vodka comparing metallica and megadeth is more like comparing mcdonald's fries and burger king's fries than french fries to vodka. |
| ______________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 1:35pm - Karma-Enema ""] let no joke swoop over thy head |
| ______________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 1:38pm - Karma-Enema ""] dumbass vodka is made from taters.....as is fries same source of derivation....different outcomes(or flavors) man i hate having to spell things out |
| ______________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 1:50pm - Karma-Enema ""] my daddy touches my in my no-no place. |
| ______________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 1:55pm - atthehaunted ""] Thank you for everyone who clarified my mistake I understood it after the first person. I did misread the title. THANX But I still think WE all have ADD haha |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 2:11pm - dreadkill ""] Karma-Enema said:dumbass vodka is made from taters.....as is fries same source of derivation....different outcomes(or flavors) man i hate having to spell things out i know that, but they are two completely different things made from the same source. metallica and megadeth were two similar bands, not two bands that sound completely different, which is why i said it was more like comparing one fast food chain's fries to another. comparing french fries and vodka is like comparing megadeth to creedence clearwater revival. both are bands with the same source instruments (guitar, drums, vocals), but they make completely different types of music that don't lend themselves to a good comparison. |
| ____________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 2:49pm - KarmaEnema ""] Karma-Enema said:my daddy touches my in my no-no place. ahahaha if your gonna pretend to be me you need to spell correctly. and how are you gonna discredit me when everyone hates me anyway? besides brad from weymouth of course |
| _____________________________ [Mar 24,2008 5:26pm - ZJD ""] Here's one I should have started with. I think Load is a way better album than The Black Album. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 5:39pm - narkybark ""] Load was aptly named. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 6:53pm - dreadkill ""] re-load and risk are better than master of puppets, peace sells, altars of madness, number of the beast, reign in blood, led zeppelin 4, rubber soul, and paul simon's call me al. |
| _____________________________ [Mar 24,2008 6:55pm - ZJD ""] I wouldn't go that far, I'd say they are better than the black album, but that's it. Also, I like Load way better than Re-Load, which i didn't think was that good. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 6:59pm - dreadkill ""] if load and reload was anything like the movie twins, load would be the danny devito twin, and reload would be the retarded mongoloid danny devito twin. none of them would be the arnold twin. |
| _________________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 7:07pm - ancient master ""] paul dianno is better than bruce dickinson any day |
| ____________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 7:27pm - Kinslayer ""] Janick is better than Dave and Andrien... hahaha JKz LOLzz |
| ____________________________________________ [Mar 24,2008 11:30pm - FuckIsMySignature ""] Load would be a great album if it wasnt composed a band named Metallica. it will continue to be overlooked because of this. |
| _______________________________ [Mar 24,2008 11:52pm - BSV ""] Conspiracy > "Them" Judas Priest > Iron Maiden Soulside Journey/Panzerfaust/Total Death > Blaze in the Northern Sky/Under a Funeral Moon/Transilvanian Hunger |
| ________________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 12:04am - neverpurified ""] FuckIsMySignature said:Load would be a great album if it wasnt composed a band named Metallica. it will continue to be overlooked because of this. agreed 100% there's some great songs on that album |
| ______________________________ [Mar 25,2008 12:22am - ZJD ""] BSV said: Judas Priest > Iron Maiden Mercyful Fate > (Judas Priest + Iron Maiden) x 10 |
| _______________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 12:29am - ThirdKnuckle ""] Metallica died when Cliff died, right after that they ran out of Mustaine-written material. they used Mustaine's stuff (check the songwriting credits) on every album through "...and Justice For All". They haven't written ANYTHING GOOD since that album, and it's 20 YEARS OLD the Black Album is a sell-out, commercial piece of crap |
| _______________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 12:30am - ThirdKnuckle ""] ThirdKnuckle said:Metallica died when Cliff died, right after that they ran out of Mustaine-written material. they used Mustaine's stuff (check the songwriting credits) on every album through "...and Justice For All". They haven't written ANYTHING GOOD since that album, and it's 20 YEARS OLD the Black Album is a sell-out, commercial piece of crap i agree |
| _________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 1:13am - Martins ""] ThirdKnuckle said: ThirdKnuckle said:Metallica died when Cliff died, right after that they ran out of Mustaine-written material. they used Mustaine's stuff (check the songwriting credits) on every album through "...and Justice For All". They haven't written ANYTHING GOOD since that album, and it's 20 YEARS OLD the Black Album is a sell-out, commercial piece of crap i agree THROUGH ...And Justice For All? I'm pretty sure that none of the songwriting credits go to Mustaine on Justice which I personally thing is the best Metallica album and equal to Rust in Peace. |
| _____________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 3:34am - AUTOPSY_666 ""] BSV said:Conspiracy > "Them" No way. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 10:36am - KPANZER ""] ROLLINS BAND>BLACK FLAG |
| _______________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 10:37am - ThirdKnuckle ""] Martins said: ThirdKnuckle said: ThirdKnuckle said:Metallica died when Cliff died, right after that they ran out of Mustaine-written material. they used Mustaine's stuff (check the songwriting credits) on every album through "...and Justice For All". They haven't written ANYTHING GOOD since that album, and it's 20 YEARS OLD the Black Album is a sell-out, commercial piece of crap i agree THROUGH ...And Justice For All? I'm pretty sure that none of the songwriting credits go to Mustaine on Justice which I personally thing is the best Metallica album and equal to Rust in Peace. yes, THROUGH "...and Justice For All"; Mustaine wrote parts of "To Live is to Die" |
| ____________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 10:41am - dreadkill ""] ZJD said: BSV said: Judas Priest > Iron Maiden Mercyful Fate > (Judas Priest + Iron Maiden) x 10 i agree with this one 100%. i love priest and maiden, but mercyful fate i like mercyful fate way more. |
| ____________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 10:42am - dreadkill ""] the black album has some really good tunes on it. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 10:52am - KPANZER ""] As long as DISCHARGE records,tapes,cd's & mp3's exsist, there is no reason to listen to any other d-beat,crust or punk band.* *this also makes 75% of all metal bands useless as well. |
| ________________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 11:47am - The Revealer ""] Y'know what Sepultura needs? More black guys. |
| _________________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 12:09pm - DestroyYouAlot ""] PEANUT BUTTER < CHOCOLATE |