Controversial metal opinions[views:32429][posts:200]__________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 12:38pm - Martins ""] ThirdKnuckle said: Martins said: ThirdKnuckle said: ThirdKnuckle said:Metallica died when Cliff died, right after that they ran out of Mustaine-written material. they used Mustaine's stuff (check the songwriting credits) on every album through "...and Justice For All". They haven't written ANYTHING GOOD since that album, and it's 20 YEARS OLD the Black Album is a sell-out, commercial piece of crap i agree THROUGH ...And Justice For All? I'm pretty sure that none of the songwriting credits go to Mustaine on Justice which I personally thing is the best Metallica album and equal to Rust in Peace. yes, THROUGH "...and Justice For All"; Mustaine wrote parts of "To Live is to Die" Alright cool but "To Live is to Die" isn't the only song on that album. And, according to Wikipedia (WHICH IS ALWAYS ALWAYS TRUE!!!!!), the credits go to Cliff Burton, Lars, and Hetfield. Oh well. Nice use of a semi-colon. |
| __________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 12:42pm - W3 nli ""] DestroyYouAlot said:PEANUT BUTTER < CHOCOLATE dood WTF, you can have both in a delicious treat |
| ____________________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 12:47pm - FuckIsMySignature ""] W3%20nli said: DestroyYouAlot said:PEANUT BUTTER < CHOCOLATE dood WTF, you can have both in a delicious treat bennyhillifier |
| __________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 12:54pm - W3 nli ""] HOLY SHIT |
| _____________________________ [Mar 25,2008 2:32pm - ZJD ""] KPANZER said:As long as DISCHARGE records,tapes,cd's & mp3's exsist, there is no reason to listen to any other d-beat,crust or punk band.* *this also makes 75% of all metal bands useless as well. No |
| _________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 2:42pm - W3 nli ""] ZJD said: KPANZER said:As long as DISCHARGE records,tapes,cd's & mp3's exsist, there is no reason to listen to any other d-beat,crust or punk band.* *this also makes 75% of all metal bands useless as well. No actually that a pretty cut statement, however id throw Doom and His Hero Is Gone in there too |
| ___________________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 3:34pm - dudebropocalypse ""] BSV said:Conspiracy > "Them" I totally agree with that. "Them" definitely has some classic, definitive King Diamond moments (e.g. "GRAANNNNNDMAA") and the narrative aspect of it is really strong, but Conspiracy has heavier riffs and more diversity between songs. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 3:43pm - dreadkill ""] early mercyful fate > king diamond (the band not the guy) |
| _____________________________ [Mar 25,2008 4:09pm - ZJD ""] dreadkill said:early mercyful fate > king diamond (the band not the guy) Agreed, but I don't think this is at all controversial. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 4:15pm - dreadkill ""] ZJD said: dreadkill said:early mercyful fate > king diamond (the band not the guy) Agreed, but I don't think this is at all controversial.i figured it was a bit against popular opinion, since king diamond is more popular and i hear more people talking about the greatness of that stuff and not as many talking about mercyful fate, but not very controversial. |
| ______________________________ [Mar 25,2008 4:41pm - Blue ""] menstrual_sweatpants_disco said:95% of death metal = boring. dont forget.... 95% of black metal = just as bad. oh, and judas priest = iron maiden = mercyful fate. i couldnt choose between just one. |
| __________________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 4:44pm - corpus_colostomy ""] how about 95% of contemporary music is bad... the top 5% makes life worth living..no? :gun: |
| ________________________________________ [Mar 25,2008 5:39pm - DestroyYouAlot ""] W3%20nli said: DestroyYouAlot said:PEANUT BUTTER < CHOCOLATE dood WTF, you can have both in a delicious treat Funny part is, I somehow reversed the arrow on that - when CLEARLY it should read "PEANUT BUTTER > CHOCOLATE." How silly of me. |
| __________________________________ [Mar 31,2008 2:14pm - rotivore ""] Morbid Angel formulas fatal to the flesh>gateways to annihlation, heretic, and domination |
| _______________________________________________________ [Mar 31,2008 2:33pm - thuringwethil at the library ""] Piggy > Dimebag |
| ___________________________________________ [Mar 31,2008 2:36pm - FuckIsMySignature ""] Ihsahn > Chuck |
| ______________________________ [Mar 31,2008 3:18pm - Yeti ""] Burzum >>>>>>>> Mayhem |
| ________________________________ [Mar 31,2008 4:14pm - xmikex ""] TLC > Destiny's Child |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 31,2008 8:50pm - demondave ""] Count Grishnacht's vocals sucked except for Filosofem. And that probably wasn't his idea to put the distortion on them. If the other lp's had that effect, I would listen to them a lot more. Filosofem is his best release both musically and in sound. |
| _________________________________________ [Mar 31,2008 8:57pm - ancient master ""] rotivore said:Morbid Angel formulas fatal to the flesh>gateways to annihlation, heretic, and domination Dave Vincent > anything with Steve Tucker, but I dont think thats controversial? |
| _________________________________________ [Mar 31,2008 8:59pm - ancient master ""] capricornus is a shitty drummer |
| _________________________________________ [Mar 31,2008 9:35pm - Conservationist ""] Pantera is closer to Emo than Death Metal. |
| ___________________________________ [Mar 31,2008 9:36pm - dreadkill ""] thuringwethil%20at%20the%20library said:Piggy > Dimebagthat isn't controversial, it is fact. |
| ____________________________________ [Apr 1,2008 3:18pm - unholy_dave ""] i didn't read the whole thread in detail but i'm pretty damn certain no one has said this, which i whole-heartedly believe: I've never seen Slayer. The only album i own is "Undisputed Attitude", which i bought when i was in high school, before i was into a lot of metal. After hearing Tom Araya sing sing the last line of "Guilty of Being White" as "guilty of being right", i decided those pricks would never see another cent of my money. True story. also, illegible band logos* are fucking retarded and obnoxious. *this does not apply to Darkthrone's logo, for example, because it is in fact legible. And badass as hell. |
| _____________________________ [Apr 1,2008 3:24pm - Yeti ""] demondave said:Count Grishnacht's vocals sucked except for Filosofem. And that probably wasn't his idea to put the distortion on them. If the other lp's had that effect, I would listen to them a lot more. Filosofem is his best release both musically and in sound. one of the things that kept me from liking Filosofem for a long time was his vocals. i thought they sounded so weak and lost all of their insane shriek. i love Filosofem, i just wish he sounded more like the early stuff. he sounds absolutely incredible on Det Som En Gang Var. |
| _____________________________ [Apr 1,2008 3:26pm - Yeti ""] also, the distortion was his idea. he used a headset so the microphone would sound like that. |
| ______________________________________ [Apr 1,2008 3:31pm - Hung_to_Bleed ""] At the Gates > Death |
| ___________________________________ [Apr 1,2008 3:33pm - fagpatrol ""] all of you > homos |
| _______________________________________ [Apr 1,2008 11:08pm - neverpurified ""] demondave said:Count Grishnacht's vocals sucked except for Filosofem. And that probably wasn't his idea to put the distortion on them. If the other lp's had that effect, I would listen to them a lot more. Filosofem is his best release both musically and in sound. how about, count grishnacht sucks in general. burzum is fucking terrible, and the only reason burzum gets recognition nowadays is because grishnacht killed his bandmate |
| ___________________________________ [Apr 1,2008 11:10pm - dreadkill ""] fagpatrol said:all of you > homoswe are all greater than homos? |
| ________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 12:54am - xmikex ""] unholy_dave said:After hearing Tom Araya sing sing the last line of "Guilty of Being White" as "guilty of being right", i decided those pricks would never see another cent of my money. It didn't strike you as odd to judge an entire band's catalog based off a cover album? I'm not out to change anybody's mind here, do what you do. But all the metal bands you listen to that draw influence from Slayer... it definitely didn't come from Undisputed Attitude. |
| ________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 12:56am - xmikex ""] dreadkill said: fagpatrol said:all of you > homoswe are all greater than homos? HAHAHA That brings me back to 5th grade in glorious Brockton public schools watching kids have meltdowns over the greater than, less than signs. I never got why so many people fail so hard at it. |
| ____________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 9:27am - unholy_dave ""] xmikex said: unholy_dave said:After hearing Tom Araya sing sing the last line of "Guilty of Being White" as "guilty of being right", i decided those pricks would never see another cent of my money. It didn't strike you as odd to judge an entire band's catalog based off a cover album? I'm not out to change anybody's mind here, do what you do. But all the metal bands you listen to that draw influence from Slayer... it definitely didn't come from Undisputed Attitude. no, i realize that. i like slayer's music. i just don't want to give my money to a racist. |
| _______________________________ [Apr 2,2008 9:57am - xmikex ""] unholy_dave said: no, i realize that. i like slayer's music. i just don't want to give my money to a racist. Alright cool. But food for thought... This song: I'm sorry For something I didn't do Lynched somebody But I don't know who You blame me for slavery A hundred years before I was born Guilty of being white I'm a convict Of a racist crime I've only served 19 years of my time Guilty of being white Written by this guy: [img] Sung by this guy: [img] A song about inheriting undeserved racism, written by a guy who's spent his whole life talking about tolerance and listening to people and being a pussy, sung by a guy who is, well... Chilean. I think you might have gotten the message of the song mixed up. Anyone else care to offer an opinion? |
| ______________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 10:18am - quintessence ""] Deicide is terrible and have really only ever written one song... |
| _____________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 10:28am - Martinsnli ""] Meshuggah is one of the worst bands I've ever tried to listen to. |
| ______________________________ [Apr 2,2008 10:31am - Yeti ""] Hung_to_Bleed said:At the Gates > Death you'll burn in Hell for that one. |
| ______________________________ [Apr 2,2008 10:32am - Yeti ""] Morbid Angel is "meh" at best. |
| _____________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 11:45am - unholy_dave ""] xmikex said: A song about inheriting undeserved racism, written by a guy who's spent his whole life talking about tolerance and listening to people and being a pussy, sung by a guy who is, well... Chilean. I think you might have gotten the message of the song mixed up. Anyone else care to offer an opinion? no, i get all that. but the fact that Araya changes the lyric in the last line from "white" to "right"...something about that makes me feel unclean or something man, i dunno. |
| ______________________________ [Apr 2,2008 12:48pm - poop ""] speaking of ian mackaye fugazi>minor threat |
| ____________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 1:13pm - AUTOPSY_666 ""] Hung_to_Bleed said:At the Gates > Death [img] |
| ___________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 1:26pm - Kinslayer ""] ancient%20master said:capricornus is a shitty drummer Who disputes this? |
| __________________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 2:43pm - FuckIsMySignature ""] Yeti said:Morbid Angel is "meh" at best. agreed Hate Eternal > Morbid Angel |
| _________________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 2:44pm - corpus_colostomy ""] haha now we gettin' contraversial yo! |
| ________________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 2:56pm - BobNOMAAMRooney ""] Tensions escalated over the weekend as Newfag forces suffered heavy losses against the battle-ready 4chan party van believed to be piloted by known terrorist Pedobear. Crushing the previously impenetrable wall made out of diamond the v-tech powered Party Van mowed down the overmatched 420chan reservists and proceeded to do donuts on the dying and dead bringing the death toll to well over 9000. Burying his face in his palm Captain Jean Luc Picard of the Newfag Defense Force contemplated chargin' his lazor should the party van's attacks continue, "Obviously we don't want to shoop da' whoop but the /b/tards leave us no choice." Rumors that the NDF was prepared to unleash Longcat in addition to lazors fueled rampant speculation that UN intervention was imminent. |
| ___________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 3:02pm - Kinslayer ""] FuckIsMySignature said: Yeti said:Morbid Angel is "meh" at best. agreed Hate Eternal > Morbid Angel fucking blasphemy... Morbid Angel = Best DM band EVAR! |
| _______________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 3:05pm - DestroyYouAlot ""] FuckIsMySignature said:Ihsahn > Chuck Well, yeah. Yeti said:Burzum >>>>>>>> Mayhem I'll go for it, sure. xmikex said:TLC > Destiny's Child How is that even controversial? Common knowledge. fagpatrol said:all of you > homos Yeth. neverpurified said: demondave said:Count Grishnacht's vocals sucked except for Filosofem. And that probably wasn't his idea to put the distortion on them. If the other lp's had that effect, I would listen to them a lot more. Filosofem is his best release both musically and in sound. how about, count grishnacht sucks in general. burzum is fucking terrible, and the only reason burzum gets recognition nowadays is because grishnacht killed his bandmate Neh. Talented kid, found himself in an unusual situation and under some unusual influences, worked his way into a few sketchy ideas but a lot of good ones, and put out some really creative music. Then killed a dude. Ended up doing some pretty cool writing in prison. Lifetime achievement, I give him a B+. xmikex said: dreadkill said: fagpatrol said:all of you > homoswe are all greater than homos? HAHAHA That brings me back to 5th grade in glorious Brockton public schools watching kids have meltdowns over the greater than, less than signs. I never got why so many people fail so hard at it. SRSLY. The alligator eats the bigger number because it's hungry. IT'S SCIENCE, GODDAMMIT. unholy_dave said: xmikex said: A song about inheriting undeserved racism, written by a guy who's spent his whole life talking about tolerance and listening to people and being a pussy, sung by a guy who is, well... Chilean. I think you might have gotten the message of the song mixed up. Anyone else care to offer an opinion? no, i get all that. but the fact that Araya changes the lyric in the last line from "white" to "right"...something about that makes me feel unclean or something man, i dunno. It's called "being intentionally provocative to offend sensitive people." You should try it sometime. BobNOMAAMRooney said:Tensions escalated over the weekend as Newfag forces suffered heavy losses against the battle-ready 4chan party van believed to be piloted by known terrorist Pedobear. Crushing the previously impenetrable wall made out of diamond the v-tech powered Party Van mowed down the overmatched 420chan reservists and proceeded to do donuts on the dying and dead bringing the death toll to well over 9000. Burying his face in his palm Captain Jean Luc Picard of the Newfag Defense Force contemplated chargin' his lazor should the party van's attacks continue, "Obviously we don't want to shoop da' whoop but the /b/tards leave us no choice." Rumors that the NDF was prepared to unleash Longcat in addition to lazors fueled rampant speculation that UN intervention was imminent. [/WIN] |
| _____________________________ [Apr 2,2008 3:07pm - BSV ""] Capricornus is definately one of the sloppiest drummers I've ever heard. But do enjoy his style rather lot. Dismember > At the Gates |
| ________________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 3:35pm - BobNOMAAMRooney ""] Fighting continued in the beleaguered chans as anonymous /b/tards continued to oppose the Internet Haet Machine's decision to grant much maligned television nerd Milhouse van Houten meme status. Skirmishes began last Thursday, as long time residents of /b/ took to the streets carrying signs assailing Newfags and chanting slogans against, "the cancer that is killing." Protesters clashed with the Newfag backed police force on 7chan Avenue and Fark Circle in the Green Zone before retreating to their stronghold on /b/. Newfag police arrested 85 protestors, about half of whom were transported via WAAAAAHmbulance to local medical centers |
| __________________________________________ [Apr 2,2008 3:44pm - mikeofdecrepitude ""] True Doom such as Evoken kill all other metal styles just by turning their amps on. A Blade of Grass > Dismember (except Like an everflowing stream) |